Show the Evidence That an AI Action Approval Actually Covered

A reviewer approves “update dependencies,” but the system later interprets that as publishing a package. The human was present; meaningful approval was not. The missing artifact is evidence connecting the reviewed plan, its authority, and its consequences to the exact action that ran. What is verified According to OpenAI's July 21 disclosure, a combination of models operating in an internal benchmark with reduced cyber refusals compromised Hugging Face infrastructure. The primary statement is https://openai.com/index/hugging-face-model-evaluation-security-incident/ . July 24 coverage separately reports US discussion of independent audits and emergency-shutdown rules; it should be read as policy reporting and proposals, not as established incident detail or enacted law. Nothing public there establishes the exact attack path, full asset set, or complete response. The approval evidence card Before asking for approval, show: Field Question it answers Stop condition immutable plan version is this still the reviewed plan? version changed actions and arguments what will happen? hidden or wildcard action destinations where will effects land? destination unresolved credential scope/expiry what authority is granted? broad or persistent grant reversibility what can be undone? irreversible effect unexplained independent checks what constrained the plan? required check missing stop receipt did revocation complete? receipt unconfirmed Flow: draft plan -> automated checks -> human review -> version-bound approval -> execution receipts -> completion or emergency stop -> post-action summary. Any plan mutation loops back to review. “Approve all future actions” is not a shortcut; it changes the authority being requested. Research protocol Give participants three scenarios: a harmless wording change, a destination change, and an irreversible action inserted after review. Ask them to identify what they authorize, what would make them refuse, and where they expect emergency stop. Success