今日已更新 340 条资讯 | 累计 26323 条内容
关于我们

How I improved BMAD with one simple skill

popiol 2026年07月05日 17:26 4 次阅读 来源:Dev.to

When asked how I evaluate BMAD recently I said haven't quite decided yet, but it definitely has strong sides and makes development faster. Of course, it dependss what you are currently work on. If you work in scrum and handle single tasks from Jira, you probably won't fin BMAD useful in any way. It's strength is in handling large projects which have to be taken from brainstorming, through requirement specification to proper design and implementation plan. BMAD does really good job in asking the right questions and pushing you into providing all necessary details. The only thing I found a bit discouraging was the boring implementation phase where you just keep clicking approve. I was recently pointed to Superpowers framework, which apparently deosn't have that problem and does the implementation part without human interaction. I tested it, but to be honest I wasn't impressed. In my case it didn't work so good. The whole planning phase comes down to brainstorming and implementation plan. This is clearly not meant to be handling large complex projects. In BMAD you have several distinct steps where each of them is handled with care and brings value to the final design. First, the brainstorming in BMAD pushes you into providing all available information, any documents you may already have and then asks a bunch of questions. Superpowers is more like: give me a brief intro and I will make up the rest. In BMAD, brainstorming is just the start, then you go to PRD, UX and architecture. You have to really spend some time to get it right, but that's exactly the real value, you spend the effort on planning, but save long hours of searching for bugs in the implementation or re-implementing the solution. Having said that, I am going to keep using BMAD, but there is still the issue I mentioned, and it has to be taken care of. The implementation itself is a pain. It's not just the approval thing, this can be fixed easily, by running cluade with --dangerously-skip-permissions , which

本文内容来源于互联网,版权归原作者所有
查看原文